Digital Ethnographic Mapping

I am currently working with a public sector client to develop a communication strategy for the stakeholders (charities, public service providers, community groups) in one of the poorest neighborhoods in the UK. For most private and public sector organizations, social media has become the default mode of communicating with the public. However, the stakeholders in this neighborhood have realized that if they rely solely on social media to communicate, they only reach a fraction of residents. Due to the number of people who are either elderly, recent immigrants who don’t speak English, or are considered socially marginalized due to poverty and lack of literacy, a smaller percentage of the population of this neighborhood uses the internet (compared to mainstream UK use). Residents who use the internet are not plugged into the social networks via which stakeholders communicate. How then can stakeholders effectively and inclusively communicate with all the neighborhood residents and not just a small percentage?

In order to understand how communication flows in this neighborhood, I’ve developed a unique research design. In the past, data in this neighborhood has primarily been collected via focus groups and surveys. Having read these research reports, I recognize that these methods have yielded valuable information. However, ethnographic research can provide much more valuable insight that is currently missing.

To start, I’ve mapped the neighborhood ethnographically and then, digitally. This means that I literally walked through this neighborhood, along its borders, through its estates, and its commercial high streets, and photographed every single storefront and public institution, such as doctors’ surgeries, off-licenses, churches, pubs, day-care centers, and chicken shops.

newsand wine

One reason to conduct this mapping exercise is to create an accurate geography for anyone who wants to visualize and understand this area. In this process, I’ve noticed that google maps neglects poor areas. If you rely on such technology, it gives the mistaken appearance that poor urban areas are empty wastelands. Also, in this process, I’ve discovered that google maps often provides out-of-date information. Stores listed on google maps simply do not exist, either having closed years ago or are in the wrong spot.

The mapping also helps me understand how the neighborhood is organized. Is it one coherent neighborhood, in which a central commercial area acts as the motor? Or is it broken up into subsections, each clustered around one of the several commercial areas dotted through the neighborhood? Or perhaps the neighborhood is divided into estates in which each estate has its own mini-lifeworld?

I’ve integrating the photos that I’ve taken into a digital map. The map is both a tool for insight and activation. Those who have access to this map can then click on a tagged point to see a photo of the space. I’ve created this map in order to make this neighborhood come alive for anyone who wants to understand my research and analysis and the types of challenges faced in the neighborhood before planning an intervention.

On a basic level, the map shows clusters of social and commercial areas to understand  the geography of this neighborhood. Looking more in depth at the photos of the social and commercial spaces, one can also understand other aspects of this neighborhood that a focus group report cannot reveal. This neighborhood is peppered with empty storefronts as well as businesses that may exist on paper but are either used as housing or for potentially dubious purposes .

sun singing chinese restaurant 23a malvern

Moreover, the existing small businesses clearly need support to maintain their physical infrastructure. The decrepit physical state of many business indicated that they may require other types of support– such as administrative or management– as well.

stitching room tailor

Moreover, I was surprised by the number of social and community institutions and the excellent state of their physical infrastructure. I  further unexpectedly found a wide range of religious groups that have well-maintained meeting spaces in this neighborhood, including Islamic groups from Eastern Europe and the Middle East and several different Christian church denominations.

This digital ethnographic mapping exercise has enabled me to identify communication opportunities without having conducted one interview. Yay ethnography!

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Digital Ethnographic Mapping

  1. I really like the idea of an digital ethnography to uncover the kinds of resources available or potentially available in a given community. In my work at HarvardX, I think a lot of how we can find out more about our globally distributed online “student body.” Some of our courses have tens of thousands of student with a huge range in terms of their actual engagement with the courses.

    Your piece makes me think that we should try to learn more about what type of community based assets students have (or could have) to support their academic work. For example, there might be high-school students who would benefit from having someone at a library or community center be in conversation with them about their courses.

    (more later)

    thank you for the inspiring piece, Nazima.

  2. Hi there,

    Thank you so much for your supportive feedback. I’m so glad to hear that this piece is helping you with your current project. Please keep me updated. I’d love to hear more about your work and ways that we could potentially collaborate.

  3. Have you ever integrated interview data collection (online or face-to-face) with mapping? I am looking for examples of research that does so– locating interview responses in a place relevant to the discussion, or mapping interview data.

  4. Hi Janet,

    Thanks for your comment. Conducting face to face interviews with residents and stakeholders and integrating these interviews into the digital map is exactly the next step in the research design! I’ll keep you updated with how it goes.

    1. Hi Fari, Thanks for your encouragement. At this moment, I’m waiting to hear from the client if they want the opportunities to be made public. Once they have decided, I’ll let you know.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s